This no mayo potato salad is the one I make when I want something lighter than the classic creamy versions. Warm Jersey Royals (or any waxy new potatoes) get tossed in a simple lime, mint and butter dressing that soaks straight into the potatoes for a fresh, zesty finish. If you’re planning a buffet, you might also like my Carrot & Courgette Sesame Salad.
We usually keep it simple with peas (because they’re always in the freezer), but it’s brilliant with asparagus in spring or a handful of blanched green beans too.
The beauty of Jersey Royals (Baby Jersey Royals like I used in my recipe) is that there is no need to peel, giving your salad an earthy, nutty taste. Just a quick scrub under running water and you are set to go. I chopped each Baby Royal in half which speeds up the cooking and makes assembly of the salad super quick afterwards.
A few facts about Jersey Royals:
- Jersey Royals can only be called that if they are grown on Jersey.
- Their heritage dates back over 140 years.
- Jersey Royals are a protected name (PDO) under the UK scheme – Like Wensleydale Cheese & Melton Mowbray Pork Pies.
Ingredients for No Mayo Lime & Mint Potato Salad
- Jersey Royal Potatoes – Or any waxy salad potato that won’t fall apart when cooked. You want your potatoes to keep their shape. Maris Piper and King Edward potatoes do not really work in a potato salad.
- Butter – Real butter brings out the flavours of the vegetables really well. If you are avoiding butter, you can try to use Olive Oil instead.
- Lime (Zest & Juice) – Don’t omit the zest, it really makes the difference and is worth doing.
- Fresh Mint Leaves – I haven’t tried using dried mint but its worth a try if you have no fresh.
- Garden Peas – Frozen are great but fresh are equally as good!
- Salt & Pepper – I really like a sprinkle of coarse sea salt just before serving and a grind of black pepper but add according to taste.
FAQs
What is a good substitute for mayonnaise in potato salad?
A lot of people struggle with the texture of mayonnaise and this potato salad is perfect for them. This Lime & Mint Potato Salad contain no hidden nasties or preservatives, just simple ingredients – Butter does have high calories so needs to be used in moderation. Olive oil makes a good substitute if you prefer but butter definitely tastes better in this recipe.
Can potato salad be healthy?
It can definitely be healthier than many shop bought, pasta salads. To make this salad even healthier, increase the amount of vegetables you add.
What kind of potatoes are best for potato salad?
Waxy potatoes like Jersey Royals (used in this recipe), Charlotte potatoes and Desiree all work well.
Can I make this ahead?
You can make this the day before but it is better to make it on the day.
Can I freeze potato salad?
No, potato salad does not freeze well as the potatoes can go slimy when defrosted.
LIME & MINT POTATO SALAD
Lime and Mint No Mayo Potato Salad
Equipment
- 1 Pan Medium
- 1 Grater For zesting your lime
Ingredients
- 450 grams Salad Potatoes Jersey Royal or Waxy potatoes
- 50 grams Butter
- 1 medium Lime
- 9 medium Fresh Mint Leaves
- 50 grams Frozen Peas
- Salt & Pepper
Instructions
- Halve baby potatoes (leave very small ones whole). Boil in salted water for ~12 minutes until just tender.
- Add peas for the last 2 minutes. Drain well, then leave the potatoes in the hot pan for 1 minute to steam-dry.
- Melt butter. Stir in lime juice + zest (stir well).
- Stir in mint, then season with pepper (and salt if needed – I really like a sprinkle of coarse sea salt).
- Toss through the warm potatoes and peas. Serve warm, or cool then chill.
Nutrition
More picnic-friendly favourites
I’ve made sure all of the recipes linked are vegetarian.
- Storecupboard BBQ CousCous is great for serving at buffets as the recipe can easily be doubled/tripled to make LOADS.
- Healthier Oven Baked Vegetable Samosas can be served hot or cold. Beware though, they are very moorish, so make lots.
- Roasted Red Pepper Hummus is a real crowd pleaser. Serve with Wholemeal Soda Dipping Sticks.
- Mushroom and Walnut Palmiers – Easy and quick to make but impressive on the plate.
Now this sounds like an interesting mix of flavours! I wouldn’t have thought of doing a mint potato salad but I bet it tastes wonderful, I’ll have to try it out.
Potato salad is my absolute favourite in summer, and this one sounds so refreshing!
Great easy recipe great for summer
I love a mayoless potato salad. This looks lovely and light and perfect for summer.
I love a warm potato salad and the addition of lime juice and zest is a great idea and perfect for the lovely weather we’ve been having!
I do love these potatoes and the idea of lime and mint in them sounds really tasty x
I’m not even a big potato fan, but this has made me feel so hungry! It looks delicious! x
Such a tasty looking salad, Jersey Royal potatoes are so delicious!
I love jersey potatoes and often get this from Tesco myself. This is a fab recipe which you have shared, will definitely try it out the next time I get the potatoes.
What an easy recipe, we love new potatoes so I will definitely try this. Thanks
We love potato salad and this one sounds ideal to go with the BBQ we’re hosting next weekend! I’ve saved the recipe, thanks so much for sharing 🙂
Yes. Yes. Yes!
Love potato salad without mayo. Jerseys seem a bit late this year but im.loving them. Would’ve never thought to add lime so thanks for the recipe xx
Oh these look so yummy! I do love a bit of potatoes with butter! Mmmm
I’ve been meaning to come and look at this recipe since o saw it on social media. I love jersey royals and you’re right, even though I love creamy potato salad, jerseys are not the potato for that. I will definitely be trying this. Yum yum
I love this combination in the salads. thank you for sharing this recipe. I will try it out 🙂
This sounds like a delicious recipe for a summery salad. I must give this a go for my next BBQ with friends.
this is definitely a unique spin on a classic dish – will have to try it!
That looks amazing and very simple too! Definitely one to try this summer.
This sounds like my perfect potato salad, will be making this for tea tomorrow!
I will definitely try this, thinking to add corn what you say?
I think that is a fantastic idea!
Looks like an excellent potato salad to eat whilst celebrating the queens birthday
Ooh, sounds refreshing! Might have to give this a go for one of our bbq nights!
Francesca x